Subversion: National Jewish Democratic Council Has Harmed Israel (Updated)

Let it be known that given the choice between Israel & Iran, The World’s only Jewish State or a possible 2nd Holocaust the NJDC Chose.. Obama. (Updated below)

The rally is over, the numbers were weak, the political stars were not in attendance and a major opportunity for American Jewry and the legions of Christian Zionists to show their support for Israel, America and the quest to stop an Iranian Nuclear weapon was lost.

Time to Assign Blame

Now that the rally has passed & this important event was far less than it could have been it is time to assign blame. The blame goes to leadership of American Jewish Democrats. Cloaking themselves in non partisanship they have in fact displayed the ultimate partisanship, and harmed the State of Israel.

They have illustrated more clearly than anyone ever possibly could that in this Presidential race in the US, Democratic words that flow from the Democrats & Obama ticket are hollow. If the NJDC can choose its own self interests over Israel, it means that Obama certainly can too despite his endless assurances.


The NJDC strives to educate American Jews across the country about the differences between their political candidates on issues of concern to them, particularly focusing on protecting reproductive rights, the separation of church and state and a strong US-Israel relationship.

Yet, Ira Forman and the NJDC have weakened that relationship, threatened the State of Israel, threatened Israel’s American supporters, and threatened the gamut of Pro Israel American institutions for purely partisan reasons, in an attempt to cloak their democratic candidate and fool Jewish Democrats by denying them the real differences between political candidates on critical issues, in direct contravention of NJDC’s mission statement. The difference is the Republicans were prepared to stand with Israel, the Democrat leadership chose to stand with Obama. This is indeed a KEY difference. Very educational to us in Israel, thank you.

NJDC Statements on the Anti-Ahmadinejad Rally

NJDC Calls for Withdrawal of Palin Invitation to Iran Rally – Marc R. Stanley – September 17, 2008

Monday’s protest against Ahmadinejadis too important to be tainted by partisanship. Unfortunately, the campaign of Senator John McCain is much more interested in scoring political points than insuring there is bipartisan solidarity around the anti- Ahmadinejad efforts. Therefore, we call upon the Conference of Presidents of Major Jewish Organizations to withdraw the invitation to Governor Sarah Palin andwe applaud Senator Hillary Clinton’s decision to not attend the rally after the attendance of Palin was announced.

By withdrawing Palin’s invitation, the Conference of Presidents of Major Jewish Organizations will be able to return the focus to America’s outrage towards the genocidal musings and nuclear ambitions of Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad.

This is a perversion of the truth. Too important to be tainted by partisanship? Only it seems when Obama is unwilling to send representatives. Before when Hillary Clinton, or Biden, or another surrogate might go to bolster Obama’s poor record on Israel issues the NJDC had no concerns about partisanship, it welcomed partisanship andfrankly so did I. Nothing would make an Israeli happier than to see big names stand with us in support from whatever party.

When the Republicans equally chose to send big names to support the State of Israel & America against Iranian lunacy, in the form of Sarah Palin – Democrats pulled their support and issued threats, Hillary Clinton the SENATOR FROM NEW YORK pulled her own support, decided to stay home. Then despite non partisan assurances outfits like the NJDC chose the entirely partisan option of threatening the entire event itself, the President of the Conference of Presidents of Major Jewish Organizations, and anyone else they could in a manner so shameful it has never been seen before in Malcolm Hoenlein’s own words. (HT Daled Amos)

More from the NJDC – Commending their own fear tactics and shame, disgusting.

NJDC Commends the Withdrawal of Palin’s Invitation to the Iran Rally – Marc R. Stanley, September 18, 2008

Yesterday, NJDC said that Monday’s protest against Ahmadinejad was too important to be tainted by partisanship. Today, NJDC commends the Conference of Presidents of Major Jewish Organizations, the National Coalition to Stop Iran Now, The Israel Project, United Jewish Communities, the UJA-Federation of New York and the Jewish Council for Public Affairs for making the right decision by withdrawing their invitation to Governor Sarah Palin. This decision shows that bi-partisan solidarity against President Ahmadinejad has won out over partisanship – even in this highly charged election year.

Really? No one won out here, least of all Israel.

Legal threats were issued, arms were twisted, dirty politics of the worst sort, certainly not the type supported by the avg. Jewish American irrespective of party, most especially not over an issue as critical as nuclear weapons possibly being aimed at the State of Israel. If anything major harm has been done to Obama in this highly charged election year, the NJDC has shown its true face to American Jewry, and it is an ugly one at that. Given the choice between Israel & Iran, the NJDC chooses lies, deception, coersion and most important of all.. Obama over all else, no matter who or what may be sacrificed in the process.

I already know who the better choice for Israel in America might be, how sad for the NJDC itself to have proven it so shamefully this week.

Link Update: J. Rubin has a great look at the issue and roundup of Jewish Organization reaction at PJM, suffice to say no one from both sides of the aisle is much impressed with this sorry NJDC display.


Update: Republicans Abroad Israel slams Dem leadership – Allied with Ahmadinejad

Jpost: Democrats give Ahmadinejad reason to smile

[...] In all likelihood, by getting their way and silencing Palin, the Democrats won only a Pyrrhic victory. This political gamesmanship is not going to sit well with most Jewish and pro-Israel voters-including Democrats and Independents-who take the Iranian threat seriously. The same day as the rally, the head of the International Atomic Energy Agency warned that Iran could be hiding certain nuclear activities, and estimated that Iran could go nuclear in just six months. And this past Sunday, no longer content to merely “wipe Israel off the map,”Ahmadinejad presided over a military parade with banners reading “Israel should be eliminated from the universe.”

[...] Obama’s talk of post-partisanship and “reaching across the aisle” looks increasingly divorced from reality. If his operatives can’t even bring themselves to join Republicans in something with such wide bipartisan support and national security implications as preventing the nuclearization of Iran, just where is that supposed post-partisanship going to appear? Do they not agree that the enemy is Ahmadinejad, not the GOP?

There is something very wrong with a party that insists on sitting down with Ahmadinejad without preconditions, but refuses to share a stage with the Republican Party candidate for Vice President of the United States of America.

The article is rather scathing, but entirely true. I’ve railed against US Jewish & Democratic leadership here before, but never have they given me this much heavy ammunition, when Israel itself goes up on the chopping block, well.. This time it isn’t business, it’s personal.

  • neil

    McCain just lost the election today.  His refusal to debate Obama makes him look like a coward not a statesman.  And what appears to be his support for a bailout that is the antithesis of capitalism and a transfer of money from poor to rich makes me question his intelligence.
    Obama is bad for Israel, no question.  But putting your faith in any politician – McCain included – is misguided.  If you want to do something in this world, you can only rely on one person- yourself.
    I have every confidence that Israel will do what she has to do regardless of who gets elected (no one living in Israel wants another Holocaust).  I mean if necessary you’d learn how to fly the jet-fighter yourself saus…  Just my 2 cents.

  • Pingback: Soccer Dad()

  • I don’t think things are as clear cut as the media makes it seem, there’s plenty of election left. They are hammering McCain & Palin with no end to save Obama’s tuchus. McCain doesn’t want to cancel the debate, he wanted to delay it so that he could do his legislative job as the new leader of the Republican party, that’s not a refusal, on the contrary Obama has refused to debate McCain in a series of townhall debates for a few months now.. So I’m not sure these chips fall the way described.

    Yes this bailout certainly looks ugly – I don’t know where my opinion falls, I’m inclined to disagree with a bailout, but this is an internal American economic decision let them figure it out is my instinct - At least McCain is against adding more pork & earmarks to this which is what the Democrats would like.

    Obama is clueless, he takes no positions, he just smiles like Alfred E Neuman. I think he’d be a disaster for America as well as Israel.